On Self Help Books: Why Don’t I Feel Better? The Truth About Positive Affirmations and Self-Help Books
“I am successful,” “I am a wonderful person,” “I will find love again,” and many other similar phrases that students, the broken-hearted and unfulfilled employees may repeat to themselves over and over again, hoping to change their lives. Self-help books through the ages, from Norman Vincent Peale’s The Power of Positive Thinking all the way to the latest, The Secret, have encouraged people with low self-esteem to make positive self-statements or affirmations.
New research suggests it may do more harm than good to many people.
Canadian researcher, Dr. Joanne Wood at the University of Waterloo and her colleagues at the University of New Brunswick who have recently published their research in the Journal of Psychological Science, concluded “repeating positive self-statements may benefit certain people, such as individuals with high self-esteem, but backfire for the very people who need them the most.”
The researchers asked people with and low self-esteem to say “I am a lovable person.” They then measured the participants’ moods and their feelings about themselves. The low-esteem group felt worse afterwards compared with others who did not. However, people with high self-esteem felt better after repeating the positive affirmation–but only slightly. The psychologists then asked the participants to list negative and positive thoughts about themselves. They found, paradoxically, those with low self-esteem were in a better mood when they were allowed to have negative thoughts than when they were asked to focus exclusively on affirmative thoughts.
The researchers suggest that, like overly positive praise, unreasonably positive self-statements, such as “I accept myself completely” can provoke contradictory thoughts in individuals in individuals with low self-esteem. When positive self-statements strong conflict with self-perception, the researchers argue, there is not mere resistance but a reinforcing of self-perception. People who view themselves as unlovable, for example, find that saying that are so unbelievable that it strengthens their own negative view rather than reversing it.
These findings were supported by previous research published in 1994 in the Journal of Social Psychology, showing that when people get feedback that they believe is overly positive, they actually feel worse, not better.
Dr. Wood goes even further. In her Psychology Today blog, she says that most self-help books advocating positive affirmations may be based on good intentions or personal experience, but they are rarely based on even one iota of scientific evidence. She cites psychologist Sonja Lyubomirsky’s The How of Happiness as an exception.
Does that mean positive affirmations are of absolutely no value. Not according to Dr. Wood and her co-researchers. They say they positive affirmations can help when they are part of a broader program of intervention. That intervention can take place in a number of forms such as cognitive psychotherapy or working with a coach who has expertise in the behavioral sciences.What kind of intervention is best to use to make positive affirmations most effective?
That’s where we encounter even more controversy.
Traditional cognitive psychotherapy may not be the best intervention according to Dr. Steven Hayes, a renowned psychotherapist, and author of Getting Out of Your Mind and Into Your Life. Hayes has been setting the world of psychotherapy on its ear by advocating a totally different approach.
In an article in Time magazine, John Cloud describes Hayes’ work. Hayes and researchers Marsha Linehan and Robert Kohlenberg at the University of Washington, and Zindel Segal at the University of Toronto, what we could call “Third Wave Psychologists” are focusing less on how to manipulate the content of our thoughts (a focus on cognitive psychotherapy) and more on how to change their context–to modify the way we see thoughts and feelings so they can’t control our behavior. Whereas cognitive therapists speak of “cognitive errors” and “distorted interpretation,” Hayes and his colleagues encourage mindfulness, the meditation-inspired practice of observing thoughts without getting entangled by them–imagine the thoughts being a leaf or canoe floating down the stream.
These Third Wave Psychologists would argue that trying to correct negative thoughts can paradoxically actually intensify them. As NLP trained coaches would say, telling someone to “not think about a blue tree,” actually focuses their mind on a blue tree. The Third Wave Psychologists methodology is called ACT (Acceptance and Commitment Therapy), which says that we should acknowledge that negative thoughts recur throughout our life and instead of challenging or fighting with them, we should concentrate on identifying and committing to our values in life. Hayes would argue that once we are willing to feel our negative emotions, we’ll find it easier to commit ourselves to what we want in life.
This approach may come as a surprise to many, because the traditional cognitive model permeates our culture and the media as reflected in the Dr. Phil show. The essence of the conflict between traditional cognitive psychologists and psychotherapists is to engage in a process of analyzing your way out your problems, or the Third Wave approach which says, accept that you have negative beliefs, thinking and problems and focus on what you want. Third Wave psychologists acknowledge that we have pain, but rather than trying to push it away, they say trying to push it away or deny it just gives it more energy and strength.
Third Wave Psychologists focus on acceptance and commitment comes with a variety of strategies to help people including such things as writing your epitaph (what’s going to be your legacy), clarifying your values and committing your behavior to them.
It’s interesting that that The Third Wave Psychologists approach comes along at a time when more and more people are looking for answer outside of the traditional medical model (which psychiatry and traditional psychotherapy represent). Just look at a 2002 study in Prevention and Treatment, which found that 80% people tested who took the six most popular antidepressants of the 1990′s got the same results when they took a sugar pill placebo.
The Third Wave Psychologists approaches are very consistent with much of the training and approach that many life coaches receive, inclusive of Neuro-Linguistic Programming (NLP), and many spiritual approaches to behavioral changes reflected in ancient Buddhist teachings and the more modern version exemplified by Eckhart Tolle (The Power of Now). The focus of those approaches reinforces the concepts of acceptance of negative emotions and thoughts, and rather than giving them energy and fighting with them, focus on mindfulness, and a commitment to an alignment of values and behavior.
So what can we learn from all this? Two things–first, just engaging in positive affirmations by themselves, can do harm to people with low self-esteem, and provide only little benefit for those with high-esteem, if those affirmations are not part of a comprehensive program of self-growth, preferably with a knowledgeable professional; and second, the traditional cognitive psychotherapeutic approach at trying to change people’s negative thinking through logical processes may actually be counterproductive, compared to an approach that has people accept their thoughts, not resist them and give more energy to them by thinking about them, but rather engage in positive behaviors and thinking.
On the next post, I’ll be interviewing Stephanie Frank, President of Success IQ University, a Master NLP Coach and Certified Hypnotherapist, who has worked with hundreds of individuals practicing the concepts and ideas in this blog, and achieved huge success with her clients. She’ll tell us how.
For More Free Information visit On Self Help Books
About the Author
Tom Miller
Lifestyle and Internet Marketing Consultant
Tom Miller
On Self Help Books
http://personaldevelopmentplanning.com
NLP Techniques for Personal Development – Dreams, Self Help, Passion
|
Get Out of Stuck – Conversational Hypnosis and NLP Breakthrough
$29.97
Get Out of Stuck is a transformational video that can be used an infinite number of times in order to change behavior, plan for a specific event, and create new neural pathways for flexibility and learning. Personal development coaches and training partners, Diane Ulicsni and Michael J. Emery, lead the viewer through an insightful and enjoyable process designed to eradicate limiting behaviors and …
|
|
The Subliminal Manifestation Series, Vol. One – Forgiveness & Love
$79.97
Dramatically Speed up Your Manifestation Process !…and it is as easy as watching TV.Yes, that’s right….the DVD you now hold in your hands will help you remove Negative Emotional Vibrations (TM) …and soar to the heights of Manifestation you were meant to enjoy.Negative Emotional Vibrations (TM) or NEV’s(TM) are like the sandbags or tethers that keeps a Hot Air Balloon from taking off or risin…
|
|
Fear-Less: Transcend & Break Through Fear
$79.97
Transcend your fears and discover the courage to manifest your dreams NOW! Simply push play on your DVD player… sit back… relax… comfortably watch… and let us do the rest. It’s that EASY! Fear stops us from making meaningful changes in our lives. While our comfort zones might feel secure, they can often block us from manifesting our dreams. We all have fears, some more paralyzing than oth…
|
|
Anger Management Stop Panic Attacks Subliminal Ocean Wave Cd
$14.99
This Subliminal Cd is intended to help you achieve your goal using positive affirmations that are directed to your subconscious mind.
Each subliminal recording targets your subconscious and contains positive reinforcement via spoken subliminal messages that are inaudible to the conscious. All you can consciously hear is the ocean waves track. Our subliminal CDs are created by certified hypnothera…
|
|
Stress Relief – Relaxation and Comfort , Subliminal Ocean Wave Cd
$14.99
This Subliminal Cd is intended to help you achieve your goal using positive affirmations that are directed to your subconscious mind.
Each subliminal recording targets your subconscious and contains positive reinforcement via spoken subliminal messages that are inaudible to the conscious. All you can consciously hear is the ocean waves track. Our subliminal CDs are created by certified hypnothera…
|
|
Lower Blood Pressure Subliminal CD – Lower Your Blood Pressure Naturally!!
$12.99
This is a subliminal product with hundreds of positive affirmations recorded onto one relaxing CD. Although the words aren’t audible, they are there and they are powerful! The affirmations are masked by beautiful music and soothing ocean waves. Meanwhile, as you focus on something else, or just while relaxing, the subliminal affirmations take hold in your subconscious mind. The affirmations are po…
|
|
Learn to Assert Yourself! Subliminal CD
$12.99
This is a subliminal product with hundreds of positive affirmations recorded onto one relaxing CD. Although the words aren’t audible, they are there and they are powerful! The affirmations are masked by beautiful music and soothing ocean waves. Meanwhile, as you focus on something else, or just while relaxing, the subliminal affirmations take hold in your subconscious mind. The affirmations are po…
|
|
Lucid Dreaming Subliminal Cd Ocean Waves
$16.99
This Subliminal Cd is intended to help you achieve your goal using positive affirmations that are directed to your subconscious mind.
Each subliminal recording targets your subconscious and contains positive reinforcement via spoken subliminal messages that are inaudible to the conscious. All you can consciously hear is the ocean waves track. Our subliminal CDs are created by certified hypnothera…
|
|
Forgiveness: Forgive Yourself & Others Subliminal Cd
$14.99
This Subliminal Cd is intended to help you achieve your goal using positive affirmations that are directed to your subconscious mind.
Each subliminal recording targets your subconscious and contains positive reinforcement via spoken subliminal messages that are inaudible to the conscious. All you can consciously hear is the ocean waves track. Our subliminal CDs are created by certified hypnothera…
|
|
The Nlp Brain Builder: Self-Coaching Strategies For Surviving And Thriving
$10.2
Adaptation is imperative if you want to succeed in the 21st century. THE NLP BRAIN BUILDER increases your chances of adapting to a world of change challenge and opportunity so that you not only survive but actually thrive. We all get stuck in our ways of thinking and we need to change our way of thinking in order to become more flexible better able to make decisions quickly reach solutions spot and grasp new opportunities assess short-term and long-term outcomes turn crises around prioritise etc. THE NLP BRAIN BUILDER teaches you simple and effective NLP (neuro linguistic programming) techniques that will enable you to change your way of thinking. Wendy Jago a business coach and NLP Master Practitioner reveals the powerful techniques that she has used to help her high-flying clients in both public and private sectors to become more successful. Whatever your starting point she shows you how to build mental agility just as you build physical fitness – and with its help manage and enjoy your professional and personal life much more.Adaptation is imperative if you want to succeed in the 21st century. THE NLP BRAIN BUILDER increases your chances of adapting to a world of change challenge and opportunity so that you not only survive but actually thrive. We all get stuck in our ways of thinking and we need to change our way of thinking in order to become more flexible better able to make decisions quickly reach solutions spot and grasp new opportunities assess short-term and long-term outcomes turn crises around prioritise etc. THE NLP BRAIN BUILDER teaches you simple and effective NLP (neuro linguistic programming) techniques that will enable you to change your way of thinking. Wendy Jago a business coach and NLP Master Practitioner reveals the powerful techniques that she has used to help her high-flying clients in both public and private sectors to become more successful. Whatever your starting point she shows you how to build mental agility just as you build physical fitness – and with its help manage and enjoy your professional and personal life much more.
|
|
Coaching With NLP For Dummies
$10.99
How to become an NLP practitioner?or supercharge your coaching skills with NLP One of the most popular methods for helping people achieve their life aspirations?Neuro-Linguistic Programmming, or NLP, holds the key to remaking one’s future. NLP encourages users to re-create the thought patterns common to those who excel, a process that helps gradually weed out negative or habitual thinking. Using the key elements of NLP?developing a coaching relationship, shedding light on patterns, managing emotional states, and shaping an agenda for change?this practical, inspiring guide offers the tools for helping your clients upgrade the quality of their personal or professional lives. Reveals ten powerful coaching questions, ten traps to avoid in coaching, and ten ways to enhance your coaching skills Offers tips on laying the foundation for success and quick win sessions Insights on how to tap into passion and purpose?and making goals come alive Methods for coaching yourself or your team and coaching through conflict Other books by Burton: NLP For Dummies, NLP Workbook For Dummies , and Building Self-Confidence For Dummies Ideal for those working towards becoming an NLP practitioner or master coach, Coaching with NLP For Dummies is a guidebook to life transformation?for both client and practitioner.
|
|
Business Nlp For Dummies
$16.69
Achieve business success with Neuro-linguistic Programming People around the globe use NLP to improve their communication skills, build rapport, make positive changes, and accomplish their goals. When used in a business context, NLP techniques can transform both your own and your team’s performances. This practical guide to NLP at work will help you increase your flexibility, become more influential, and achieve professional success, whatever your career. Use NLP techniques in the workplace – overcome barriers to success and develop a winning mindset Build effective working relationships – improve your communication skills and create rapport with your colleagues Lead people to perform – enhance your ability to inspire peak performance Make changes that drive success – set and achieve ambitious goals
|
|
Business NLP For Dummies
$11.99
Achieve business success with Neuro-linguistic Programming People around the globe use NLP to improve their communication skills, build rapport, make positive changes, and accomplish their goals. When used in a business context, NLP techniques can transform both your own and your team’s performances. This practical guide to NLP at work will help you increase your flexibility, become more influential, and achieve professional success, whatever your career. • Use NLP techniques in the workplace – overcome barriers to success and develop a winning mindset • Build effective working relationships – improve your communication skills and create rapport with your colleagues • Lead people to perform – enhance your ability to inspire peak performance • Make changes that drive success – set and achieve ambitious goals
|
|
Self Help
$29.99
Aaron Jasinski Self Help – Giclee Print
|
|
Transform Your Life with NLP: A Teach Yourself Guide by Jenner, Paul Edition , 1
$19.99
More than 60 million Teach Yourself products sold worldwideThe power to change your life in one bookTransform Your Life with NLP gives you the motivation and the tools you need to change any, or every, aspect of your life. You can use the NLP mindset to program your subconscious and become able to improve anything from sporting success to work performance. You can also use NLP to boost your self-esteem and to find resilience at times of stress or pressure. You don’t need to be an expert or even to have any experience of NLP–a tailored 2-week program at the end of the book will ensure you reach all your goals and help you to set new ones. Featuring self-assessment exercises, write-in review areas and other learning materials that really work, this book has the power to change your lifeIncludes:One, five and ten-minute introductions to key principles to get you startedLots of instant help with common problems and quick tips for success, based on the author’s many years of experienceAn NLP workbook for general readers to deal with personal as well as professional issues
|
|
Develop Your Nlp Skills
$12.59
Neuro-Linguistic Programming (NLP) is one of the most powerful communication tools available. It offers an in-depth understanding of what really happens when we communicate, as well as the means to use that knowledge to maximize the effectiveness of any interpersonal transaction. Any business person who has a grasp of the basic NLP concepts and techniques, and who learns to use this information effectively, can expect to enjoy real improvements in all aspects of their professional and social activities. This new edition of Develop Your NLP Skills includes new material, together with mini case studies and action points. It shows how to become more successful at work by setting effective goals, leading to more focused activity; building strong relationships with colleagues and business associates; replacing conflict with co-operation; and managing mental activities for greater self-control.
|
|
NLP Techniques Anyone Can Use
$1.19
NLP is a powerful personal change/communication model, based on solid theoretical footings – psychology, physiology, systems theory and communication. Ten typical NLP processes are described that anyone – managers, parents, coaches, etc. – can use to help themselves or others to be more resourceful, be more aware of their actions on others or to undertake interesting and challenging opportunities.
|
